I am writing this post as much to help process/vent/organize my thoughts as to solicit your encouragement and advice. If considering the minutiae of our parenting/kindergarten challenges isn't a good use of your time and energy - By all means, please skip this one!! If, however, you are a teacher, parent, psychologist, pastor... and you have some patience, grace, & wisdom to offer us... we will take all the help we can get. OR- If you are a parent and reading about our failed efforts at Kindergarten...makes you feel better about your own kiddos... yes! It is hard. We are in this together & on the stumbling parent journey with you!
Dear Blog,
We are doing our best, but we don't know what to do. We are failing at kindergarten. When I hold up the mirror and dig into my emotions, I don't know how to separate my embarrassment, anger, and shame from a straightforward approach to working through the problems.
I spent hours researching schools, filling out forms, thinking through schedules, going to screenings, going to open houses, asking questions, buying/washing/organizing school uniforms & school supplies, and on and on. We read to Oliver every night. We try to be strict, but not cruel. We limit sugar. We try to stick to bedtimes. We try to limit TV and game time. We do our best not to spoil him. We take him to playgrounds and value exercise and outdoor exposure. We moved him to the expensive Spanish immersion preschool to ensure he would have a solid Pre-K experience and be ready to go. We go to a diverse church to teach him faith, kindness, and to see people of all colors and backgrounds as family. We are doing our best to be good parents! (Dammit!)
Steve and I chose Parnassus Prep (over 3 other good elementary schools) for Oliver because we believe that when you challenge kids, they will adapt and rise to the occasion. We like the uniforms for minimizing class/social distraction. We love the focus on reading, logic, thinking, language. We like that they have a longer school year and longer school day and that they challenge the "education norms." We felt like the hours (8-3:30) fit best with our schedules and our family. We like that they start Spanish in kindergarten. We like that the student population is diverse. We like that the school is a little smaller and that it would ideally provide a community of students and parents that would align with our values and beliefs.
A month into things, it isn't going very well....
We thought the bus would be the best transportation option. Unfortunately, even though we live in the district, we are on the far end of our route. A week before school started, we got Oliver's bus times which were 6:44am with a 4:35pm drop off. The first day of school, we woke him up at 6am to leave the house by 6:30am to walk to his stop and the bus was late getting home and dropped him off around 5:15pm. It didn't help that he didn't have time to eat his lunch....3 weeks of this schedule, with losing his nap on top of things.... didn't result in him adapting... it led to total meltdowns at home and... at school.
The bus company stinks and has cycled through about 7+ drivers (!!!!) on our route and has botched communication at every stage. (Charter school equals smaller contract so we get the dregs of drivers and care.) The school has also been negligent in communicating well with parents and in limiting bus time for students... They have a policy of a maximum of one hour of riding each way for kids. (That is ride time, not based on school start/release.... ) Philosophically, I believe the buses are just a big hassle and added expense for the school and they don't care one snit about what the parents or students go through to use the bus system. They don't care if kids are exhausted or lost or late or bullied... or wetting themselves due to long rides. Not their problem.. even though they hire and contract with the company... Sadly, we learned the reality of charter school busing the hard way. The added stress + angry emails and calls to bus company and principal can not be undone and didn't do much to improve anything. It has been a total mess & I'm sure I've made a rotten impression on the principal and he lost a lot of my respect through this process, as well. The long rides and lost sleep didn't set Oliver up for success and we can't undo the damage or decisions. We are all two steps behind before we've hardly begun. I really believe the busing was a big part of the problem and I wish I could go back and do it all differently.
Some of it is growing pains, but the little bumps and bruises add up... of school losing our lunch money and sending a note telling us we had a negative balance. Teacher sending me a request to replace school supplies for Oliver that somehow got lost or misplaced... Teacher and principal not responding to my emails and then telling me calling works better after I finally tracked them down... (Even though their emails are listed everywhere with encouragement to "contact them with any questions or concerns!!") I was annoyed at the open house that my request for Oliver to be in a class with his one friend was ignored. I was annoyed that he was put in a class with the brand new (never had a class b4) teacher. I was irritated that he is in a class with the only other Oliver in kindergarten. I was anxious about him being seated at the very back of the room. I just didn't feel good about any of it.
The "processes" have also been overwhelming. There are different websites for grades, homework updates, lunch money, lunch ordering. There are email updates, and communication folders and daily homework and required reading minutes. + uniform guidelines, snacks to prepare, lunches to make, buses to catch.... we are scrambling just to figure out what to do and how to do it. Starting to figure it out one piece at a time, but it has been frenzied and we have no habits in place to support all the new "ways" we are supposed to be managing. It will get better, but out of the gates it has been a mess.
Don't sweat the small stuff, but the small stuff feels like all sorts of little signs/knicks that nag towards maybe we made the wrong choice. Maybe the teacher isn't all that great. Maybe the principal is terrible...Maybe it isn't the right fit for Oliver...Maybe the school isn't all that we thought it was...
Amidst my doubts, Oliver has been "flipping cards" and having all sorts of behavioral issues in the classroom which we really didn't know about. He has also been acting out at home so I'm not totally surprised.... On Monday, something happened where he refused to put down a pencil and somehow it escalated into two teachers, him screaming on the floor, and the principal having to come in and help remove him from the classroom. We didn't hear about it from Oliver or his teacher or the principal until the next day... (Some of it was phone tag troubles... but, STILL!!!) Apparently, mini tantrums have been his thing and he has been really difficult and disruptive overall... We feel defeated. Angry at school. Disappointed in Oliver. Disappointed in ourselves.
I am frustrated that we didn't know sooner that he was having such a hard time and I feel like we have a teacher who is overwhelmed with a new class and barely has the time or energy to help us get on top of Oliver's behavior. I think we could do it if we worked together... but, if she can barely find time to answer or send an email to keep us informed of how things are going... there isn't much we can do besides try to manage and support him blindly from home.....
So, now what? It is EASY to give up and to blame the school and to walk away. It is HARD to hold the mirror up to ourselves and to take responsibility for setting Oliver up to fail. We thought we were making good choices, but if I step backwards, I can see how we created a perfect storm for derailment.
We have been lenient and a step behind with defiant/tantrum behaviors at home over the summer. New baby and busy social calendars... we probably ignored and let too many sassy outbursts slide ourselves. He is a "young 5" and we chose a challenging academic program for him and decided to start him this year. We decided hot lunches were easier than packing.. not realizing the line wait for lunch would suck up most of his eating time....
The bus schedule was a recipe for disaster from the first minute we got the schedule. 6:44am - 4:30pm best case is a long day for a kid who is in a new routine and not getting a nap. We had no idea it would be so bad, but I wish we had simply pulled the plug immediately and driven him/carpooled instead. (We thought worth trying the new routine b4 changing it, there was construction at the school and everyone driving seemed like as much of a mess as taking the bus...we were told the bus routes would be changing after a few weeks and so decided to stick it out in hopes the routes would shorten....We had no idea the driver turnover was such an issue...)
Now we are in a position where Oliver is the "bad kid" in class and he has to fight from behind to earn his teacher's respect and affection. We are the "bad parents" who have sent angry emails, have had hard phone conversations, and have the kid who is disrupting the whole class... Oliver's teacher and principal know nothing about us except that we aren't that nice, we are pissed about busing, and that our kid is a hot behavioral mess.
I don't know what to do. I sent him out the door today with nothing but my prayers to protect and guide him.
It is like one of the seeing eye pictures where all the pixels start out as fuzzy and I hope that by stepping back and staring... it will suddenly all come into focus. I don't want to give up too easily nor do I want to be afraid to fail/pull the plug/start over if that's what we need to do.
Is this just small potatoes? We do have a good school. And, a good kid. Just a bumpy start?
- If we drive him in the morning instead of busing, he gets an extra hour of sleep.
- If he gets used to not having a nap, things will get easier for him.
- If we pack his lunch, he gets more time to eat & we have better control of his nutrition.
- If we focus in and get on top of the behavior issues -- tantrums, outbursts, disrespect at home will he be fine at school? (Our new time out and intervention plan + fierce focus on positive behavior reinforcement going into effect shortly!!)
- If we give the teachers and principal some grace and they give us a second chance will we get through it and come out better for it?
- What else can we do to make things better for O and for everyone?
OR... Are we forcing something to work that just isn't a good fit?
- Is Oliver just not ready for kindergarten and do we need to think about pulling him out and waiting another year?
- Is this the wrong school? Do we need to look at the public school or a different kindergarten transfer and start over somewhere else?
- Have we all done too much damage to recover? If school has lost our trust, and Oliver isn't thriving and the school doesn't like our kid or his parents are we already on a track that can't ever recover?
I don't know the answer to the riddle. I just know it isn't going well and we are all kind of miserable trying to improve things and figure out what to do. I feel vulnerable, embarrassed, and like we are all failing. I feel caught off guard. I tend to be a little smug about Oliver and to feel like we are mostly on top of things and that he is adorable and wonderful (obviously to our credit...). I am a fount of free parenting advice to others... And, now, we are suddenly bombing out here and completely out of our element....
Go ahead and revel in our defeat... And, then have some compassion and help us move forward. Being in the middle of it, I can't figure out what is passing and what is big. I can't separate my emotions from the issues and make good choices about how to address them. Every decision feels weighty and like we may be dooming Oliver for life if we make the wrong one...
Starting K too soon and choosing to let him ride the bus = Slow tracked and naughty labeled for life?
Moving to an easier kindergarten or giving up to easily = Giving up the opportunity to be part of an awesome learning/academic community?
No pressure.
Make a choice and keep going.... No parenting handbook or crystal ball to reference.
I know many of you who are reading this probably can see the big picture and that Oliver will be fine no matter what happens. It is 4 weeks of rough kindergarten and we are making progress on improving things day by day... It will all be fine....
However, being in the middle of the bumps and having Oliver not doing well... and second-guessing every little move we are making is madness and it feels like every choice is so weighty and important. We are stressed and worried and it is hard.
For those of you who can see the light more clearly than we can - We appreciate your wisdom, encouragement, advice, etc. I read something today that said the best thing to do when solving a problem that is too big... is to listen.
While I was writing this blog, we got the following email (sent to just Steve and not to me...(SIGH) but I guess every step is progress?)
From: "Swanson" <Swanson@parnassusprep.com>
Date: Sep 23, 2015 7:14 AM
Subject: Oliver's behavior
To: "stevewrangham@gmail.com" <stevewrangham@gmail.com>
Cc:
APPENDIX!!
Date: Sep 23, 2015 7:14 AM
Subject: Oliver's behavior
To: "stevewrangham@gmail.com" <stevewrangham@gmail.com>
Cc:
Dear Mr. Wrangham,
I wanted to email you to make sure we do not play telephone tag and are not able to reach each other. Yesterday was a much better day regarding Oliver’s behavior. He did not need one reminded all the way up to rest time. In the afternoon he did get talkative and needed reminders during instruction to sit in STAR and show respect. The reason he was not showing respect was due to talking/making noises during instruction. However, like I stated above his behavior was much better yesterday. I will be out of the classroom tomorrow afternoon and all dayFriday. I will email you Monday regarding the feedback I receive from the guest teacher. Have a great day!
Ms. Swanson
Prima Teacher
As soon as I originally posted this... I realized that I focused quite a bit on the negative and missed all the positives... I owe it to myself and to Oliver to add this list to my post:
It is not all a bust. Best things about kindergarten so far:
1) Oliver likes his teacher and repeatedly tells us Ms. Swanson is his favorite. (His favorite class is Recess.)
2) In under 4 weeks, his mastery of alphabet and numbers is already soaring.
3) He loves riding the bus and was mad at us for deciding to drive in AM instead.
4) He is making new friends. He likes having another Oliver in his class and "Olivia" is one of his favorite class mates.
5) He didn't tell us about his big tantrum because... "he forgot."
6) He rushes to do his homework every night and really likes it.
7) He is learning two new kicks in Taekwondo
8) His coloring, after 1st month, is about 100x better and he will sit and contentedly color for an hour.
9) He is trying to be good and started his own system at home of tracking when he has days with no card flips and when he has days with card flips. He was so excited to have a no card flip day yesterday that he was darn near angelic all night.
10) In spite of everything, he says he likes his school and his teacher and seems mostly just fine or as if he isn't really suffering too much despite driving his teachers nuts and making his parents worry like crazy.... Go figure.





